What would you say to this?

Thread Starter

R!f@@

Joined Apr 2, 2009
10,004


Is it an act of God...?

Will the equipment work now..?

"Do not talk abt missing components, it will create problems. besides, electronics is something nobody knows"..:eek:
...something an old guy said to me today.

As if...he obviously had no idea who he is talking to :cool:


Story time later, for now what do u say?

Higher resolution pic attached.
 

Attachments

debjit625

Joined Apr 17, 2010
790
As per me if the circuit was designed efficiently ,then the circuit is going to have problem after removing parts but many product in market have very inefficiently designed circuits as many parts in them are useless or the value selected is not proper,in most case it happens when the designer try to copy circuit section from any other module and apply it on the existing system without going for much details).

Sometime removing parts from efficiently designed circuits also not cause much problem but it will loose its efficiency.

In your case it is funny because their is no connection for those components in the pcb,I dont know about the other side of the pcb but if thats the case what you are trying to show us then it will make no difference after removing those components.

Good Luck
 

GetDeviceInfo

Joined Jun 7, 2009
2,273
Well, if you look at the high res, it would appear that the parts where placed, but then sniped out.

Somebody must have gotten their before you, and I doubt it was God, because why then would it be in your hands?
 

Thread Starter

R!f@@

Joined Apr 2, 2009
10,004
Well, if you look at the high res, it would appear that the parts where placed, but then sniped out.

Somebody must have gotten their before you, and I doubt it was God, because why then would it be in your hands?
Bingo.....we have a winner..:D

Some of u just don't get something like the more experienced ones.

What I was asking was tht do u think the component was broken off. From what I can see the PCB has been deliberately sabotaged.

I got involved in the internal affairs of a company :D
What are the odds ?
 
Last edited:

GetDeviceInfo

Joined Jun 7, 2009
2,273
i was asked to do an annual budget for a manufacturing plant one year, and an HVAC contract had me perplexed. It was running a million a year for some basic systems that should have been 1/4 of that.

It just so happended that one day the owner/operator of that contract walked into my office, presented a control board that he claimed malfunctioned and he replaced. I thanked him but asked he leave me the board.

as I was jotting down the circuit in attempts to repair, it became evident early that the board was sabotoged by someone cutting a trace.

I left the company after some preliminary questioning by the police, and never heard what the outcome was.
 

maxpower097

Joined Feb 20, 2009
816
Its not uncommon to cut traces when a component is not needed after debugging. This looks like an obvious cut trace. Who did it and why its there is another matter.
 

Thread Starter

R!f@@

Joined Apr 2, 2009
10,004
i was asked to do an annual budget for a manufacturing plant one year, and an HVAC contract had me perplexed. It was running a million a year for some basic systems that should have been 1/4 of that.

It just so happended that one day the owner/operator of that contract walked into my office, presented a control board that he claimed malfunctioned and he replaced. I thanked him but asked he leave me the board.

as I was jotting down the circuit in attempts to repair, it became evident early that the board was sabotoged by someone cutting a trace.

I left the company after some preliminary questioning by the police, and never heard what the outcome was.
Some dude cut the tracks and u got questioned ? :eek:
 

Thread Starter

R!f@@

Joined Apr 2, 2009
10,004
Its not uncommon to cut traces when a component is not needed after debugging. This looks like an obvious cut trace. Who did it and why its there is another matter.
Do u honestly think this is a trace cut?

It's missing components for god's sake

Below are the leads I desoldered from the missing Triac, mov & Res



This proves tht there was a component there before.

Whether the sewing machine was working with or without it is yet to confirm.
After repairing the board, I got completely new faults. And tht error info is also something tht was not there before.

I am too baffled as what is going on in there.
 

thatoneguy

Joined Feb 19, 2009
6,359
After repairing the board, I got completely new faults. And tht error info is also something tht was not there before.

I am too baffled as what is going on in there.
Try cutting out the parts you replaced, seemed to have worked for the last guy. :D

Got a higher resolution image of the front and back of that board? I've done a bit of repair on these with my son as a hobby.
 

Thread Starter

R!f@@

Joined Apr 2, 2009
10,004
Try cutting out the parts you replaced, seemed to have worked for the last guy. :D
This is the first repair attempt...but the old guy seems to know tht fixing the machine is an impossible task and he is irritating me with his stories :mad:

I cannot yet tell the whole story until I have fixed it and to do tht I got to read Chinese :confused:

Got a higher resolution image of the front and back of that board? I've done a bit of repair on these with my son as a hobby
I am drawing up the board to see if the missing components are indeed in use.
 
Top