In the below circuit, I would expect to see 2.5v peak AC across the Capacitor; but according to the sim, I am seeing 3.5v. Any thoughts on why?

Resistor = 12k
C = 1/(2*pi*f*C)
= 1/ (2*pi* 3.4kHz * 3.9nF)
= 12k
Since the impedance of the resistor and capacitor are both at 12k, I would expect the output voltage to be 1/2 its input voltage...
Vout = Vin *( 12 / (12 + 12))
= Vin * (12/24)
= Vin* 1/2
Where am I going wrong?
Thanks!

Resistor = 12k
C = 1/(2*pi*f*C)
= 1/ (2*pi* 3.4kHz * 3.9nF)
= 12k
Since the impedance of the resistor and capacitor are both at 12k, I would expect the output voltage to be 1/2 its input voltage...
Vout = Vin *( 12 / (12 + 12))
= Vin * (12/24)
= Vin* 1/2
Where am I going wrong?
Thanks!