TV antenna selection

Thread Starter

Georacer

Joined Nov 25, 2009
5,182
In my grandmother's house, we need to replace the old TV antenna whose performance is starting to drop over the last years.

As you can read, I live in Greece. The house is in a mountainous area, quite surrounded by mountaintops. The closest transmitter isn't exactly visible. I 'm interested in the UHF band.

What type of antenna should I look for?

Thanks in advance.
 

cork_ie

Joined Oct 8, 2011
428
I assume Greece is going Digital like the rest of Europe before the end of 2012.

What is the channel spacing ?
. If the channel frequencies are close together then a directional Yagi should do,
Channels, Aerial Group, Colour Code:
21-37 A Red
35-53 B Yellow
48-68 C/D Green


If you have wide channel spacing you will need a wideband aerial
21-48 K Grey
21-68 W Black
35-68 E Brown

If I were getting an aerial for my Granny I would see what the neighbours are using in the same location. They will also give you an indication of direction and polarity.
 

bertus

Joined Apr 5, 2008
22,277
Hello,

The Netherlands, where I live has gone digital already.
We use a DVB-T system called Digitenne.
When you do not have a subscription, you can look to the 3 non-commercial stations.
With a subscription (wich cost about 9.5 euro a month), you will get about 20 stations.

Bertus
 

Wendy

Joined Mar 24, 2008
23,421
I used to live in that kind of environment. Best solution is a directional antenna and a rotor, so you select the best set up. If the signal is weak you also need a booster, they used to be common, not sure today. Basically an antenna preamp, to amplify weak signals.
 

#12

Joined Nov 30, 2010
18,224
When I had to eliminate reflections from nearby mountains I used a log-periodic antenna...the kind with saucers on the front. They can have an aiming window as small as 5 degrees. (That means a huge front to rear ratio.) That was Los Angeles. When I had to get Chicago, I used the antenna in the first post...we call it a "screen door with bow ties". I picked up 3 different cities. Not as directional as you might like.
 
Last edited:

Thread Starter

Georacer

Joined Nov 25, 2009
5,182
There is already a commercial signal amplifier in the existing setup, but it's pretty old too and a bit weather-beaten.

Greece is indeed supposed to turn to digital by the end of the year. It's been 6 months that some areas of the country receive digital signal and last month, one of the two major transmition spots in Athens turned digital too.
I simply turned my antenna to look to the other one.

I really doubt if the analog signal will be abandoned coutry-wide by the end of the year. Schedules isn't exactly the strong point of this country.

Thank you all for your suggestions. Too bad the answer isn't a straighforward one, judging from the diversity of your responses.
 

cork_ie

Joined Oct 8, 2011
428
The Bowtie grid is a variation of the Colour King aerial .
It is a superb aerial , great for wideband but unfortunately very prone to reflections.
I live inside in a Glen , with very difficult reception and after a huge amount of trial and error found a very long Yagi the best option by far.

An ideal 20 element Yagi can theoretically give 19 dBd forward gain.
20 element is rare and expensive so you could try something shorter first, 10 or 12 element should do in most cases.

As mentioned above , I would definitely agree that a signal booster is well worth fitting. Especially when the transmitter is out of your line of sight.
They are widely available at small money. Variable gain is best in your situation
 

bertus

Joined Apr 5, 2008
22,277
Hello,

A signal booster will only help if you already can receive some signals.
You can not boost nothing to something.

Bertus
 

bountyhunter

Joined Sep 7, 2009
2,512
There is already a commercial signal amplifier in the existing setup, but it's pretty old too and a bit weather-beaten.

Greece is indeed supposed to turn to digital by the end of the year. It's been 6 months that some areas of the country receive digital signal and last month, one of the two major transmition spots in Athens turned digital too.
I simply turned my antenna to look to the other one.

I really doubt if the analog signal will be abandoned coutry-wide by the end of the year. Schedules isn't exactly the strong point of this country.

Thank you all for your suggestions. Too bad the answer isn't a straighforward one, judging from the diversity of your responses.
Do you know what channels you are trying to receive? The new "digital" antennas are built to receive all the UHF channels (14 -83) and the upper VHF band (7-13).

If you have no channels of interest in the low VHF band (2-6) just get a new digital antenna. If you have some in low VHF, you need a broadband antenna.

Here is an example of a high gain digital antenna for upper VHF-UHF:

http://www.solidsignal.com/pview.as...tdoor-HDTV-Antenna-(HBU44)&c=TV Antennas&sku=

another good one:

http://www.amazon.com/Winegard-HD7698P-HDTV-VHF-UHF-Antenna/dp/B001DFTGRY
 

cork_ie

Joined Oct 8, 2011
428
Hello,

A signal booster will only help if you already can receive some signals.
You can not boost nothing to something.

Bertus
She has already been receiving a signal for years , but the performance has dropped off and he is replacing the aerial with a new one.
It is a fair assumption that the signal level is adequate but with DVB-T pixalation can become an issue in rain.
 

Thread Starter

Georacer

Joined Nov 25, 2009
5,182
Roughly from 21-69. The upcoming digital transmitions are in that range too.

For now I am aiming to reach the analog channels. To my experience so far, digital channels reach the antennas much more clearly in the same distance and without interference so I don't think the transitions from one format to another will be an issue. Do I assume wrong?
 

cork_ie

Joined Oct 8, 2011
428
Hi Georacer,
You assume right , just that the bit of "snow" in analogue reception when it rains or if you have trees etc. growing in the signal path is not very noticeable.
With Digital it is either perfect picture or breaking up called pixelation (see attached image) , when the signal level drops.
 

Attachments

KJ6EAD

Joined Apr 30, 2011
1,581
Assorted additional antenna adjustment advice:

If all of your transmissions come from the same location, you don't gain anything with a rotor.

If your signal is knife-edging over a hill then angling the antenna above or below horizontal as well as rolling the polarity slightly may be optimal.

It's a lot easier to adjust the antenna if you have a small TV connected on the roof while adjusting it to directly observe the effect of adjustments.

Go through the adjustments in order: azimuth (yaw), elevation (pitch) and polarity (roll) then repeat to fine tune.
 
Last edited:

bountyhunter

Joined Sep 7, 2009
2,512
She has already been receiving a signal for years , but the performance has dropped off and he is replacing the aerial with a new one.
It's very odd that an antenna's performance would degrade, it's usually caused by a bad transformer or deterioration of the cable downlead.

My antennas are 25 years old and have never had any degradation, but the coax lines do have to be replaced about every 8 - 10 years. But going to a newer antenna with higher gain will give better reception.

BTW: use best quality RG-6 cable to minimize signal loss. Use "weatherproof" transformers at the antenna and seal them very well with grease and tape to keep water out.
 

Thread Starter

Georacer

Joined Nov 25, 2009
5,182
The antenna is so old we have lost track of its age. My father found it installed at his father's-in-law house 30 years ago.

I 'm willing to drop a penny or to for the local economy to replace a generation-old apparatus.

Edit: The coax has been replaced relatively recently.
 
Last edited:

crutschow

Joined Mar 14, 2008
34,452
The advantage of a booster mounted at the antenna is that it amplifies the signal before any losses from the cable between the antenna and the TV.

Look for one with a low noise figure.

The degradation you are observing with the old antenna may be due to the amplifier failing as well as the antenna weathering.
 

#12

Joined Nov 30, 2010
18,224
I'm with bountyhunter. I never throw an antenna out until I can't replace the bolts that hold the connections on. If you can install it in the attic, it will never wear out.

AntennaCraft and Wineguard are both good brands but, the Wineguards are always more expensive for the same size antenna.

I use, "electricians putty" on the connectors. The connections will be good as new after 10, or maybe even 20 years. The "best" cable right now is RG-6 Quadshield.

Radio Shack used to sell an adequet pre-amp with FM trap/or not, and adjustable gain. I don't rememeber when because I've had the same one working for over 30 years.

Yes, I'm too cheap to pay for cable TV.
 
Top