Otto Smiths patent for 3 phase motor running on 1 phase power

Thread Starter

machapungo

Joined Jan 17, 2014
20
L1-N and L2 to N are 180 degrees out of phase. That's a factor of the utility transformer bringing power to the house.

YEP! MY BRAIN GOT WRAPPED UP IN THE WYE AND FAILED TO FOCUS ON WHAT I KNEW TO BE TRUE ABOUT THE INCOMING 240V SERVICE. MUST BE OLD AGE!


No you shouldn't need the same rpm motor for the rotary converter. I believe it would be best to have one that has lots of copper and iron though. One of the old old style that weigh a ton, 1750 rpm. That's what we used.

MY 15HP IS ONE OF THOSE OLD 1750 RPM "WEIGH A TON" CRITTERS.

The system can be made to work if you like to experiment and are prepared for less than optimal performance. Perhaps a commercial unit would be an easier route.
MY HABIT & CURSE IS TO ALMOST ALWAYS TAKE THE MOST DIFFICULT PATH!
 

Thread Starter

machapungo

Joined Jan 17, 2014
20
Dear TCMTECH & TINNKERMAN,

With you two knowledgeable guys, I have obviously "HIT THE JACKPOT" even though you have different efficiency experiences for the "direct drive" / " static single phase converter" system.

I think you have covered the issues quite well and I thank you both.

My decision is to go with the tcmtech direct drive schematic especially since it was my desire to avoid buying another motor to do the other well proven approach. I'll let Otto Smith's circuit just rest in the back of my mind but it would be good to here your opinions on how he has the two wye's connected and if it would make any sense to use the 6 coils of a dual voltage 3 Ph. motor to implement the circuit. One missing element of Otto's schematic was the lack of capacitor values or any rule of thumb to calculate them for a given HP motor. If I were to try his circuit (WHICH I'M NOT) I would start out using values as per the tcmtech schematic.

The two motor solution is always there if I need it.

Would it make sense to pick up 3 cheap ac amp meters to insert, one each, into the 3 wye legs just to monitor what's going on?

There will be a delay before I can put this saw together but when I do I WILL give feedback. Even though I retired in 1999, I seem to have too many project irons in the fire plus a constant stream of "honey-do's. I like to say" I worked last century, but I'm taking this one off" I simply have to finish up restoring a vintage John Deere 316 mower & I'm almost there except for carburetor work.

Thanks for your help & any additional comments are welcome.

Regards
 

Thread Starter

machapungo

Joined Jan 17, 2014
20

tinkerman

Joined Jul 22, 2012
151
@machapungo, While not to discount anything the guys have said here, there is a forum that deals with phase converters and they have many people doing it successfully. You might have a look here for more ideas -
http://www.practicalmachinist.com/vb/transformers-phase-converters-vfd/

I haven't been there for a while, but there used to be guys getting converters balanced between the phases within ~5-10%, or lower.
Thanks for the link. Should be an interesting forum.

What I find odd is that the R&D dept. here never even mentioned or had one page of literature using the same system that the other poster offered in his drawing. Nor did a local company producing both static and rotary converters use the method offered. It differs only from what I built (and others sold commercially) only by the addition of a capacitor(s) from the opposite leg of the single phase supply to the produced phase.

It will be easy to clip in additiona capacitors into my system and do some live readings. Will certainly follow up on that soon.
 

tcmtech

Joined Nov 4, 2013
2,867
Given you have an 8 gauge circuit if the length from your 200 amp service panel to your motor is not too long it should work. Mine is on 6 gauge aluminum wire and about 15 feet from my breaker panel.

Also being its running a saw the starting loads should be fairly light so it will get up to speed quickly.
My 15 HP air compressor runs off a 3450 RPM motor and the compressor itself has a flywheel that weighs a good 70 pounds. Combined thats a lot of mass to get up to speed but still mine has been doing it for at least 7 years now without any issues. :)

BTW for starting capacitors I cheated on mine and used a pair of old 450 VDC 2800 uf electrolytics from a old industrial power supply. I have then wired reverse series with ones positive as the input then their negative terminals tied in series with the second capacitors positive as the output. SO far I have never had an issue with them working that way even though they take a 100 or so amp current through them for 3 - 10 seconds while the compressor gets up to speed.

The reverse series connection makes them work as an equivalent to a 1400 uf 300 VAC motor start capacitor. ;)

For your 15 HP motor I would start out with around 150 uf for each of the phase balancing capacitors and at least 1000 uf for the starting capacitor. The size of the starting capacitor determines the starting torque and thus starting speed up time and starting amp load.
 

Thread Starter

machapungo

Joined Jan 17, 2014
20
Given you have an 8 gauge circuit if the length from your 200 amp service panel to your motor is not too long it should work. Mine is on 6 gauge aluminum wire and about 15 feet from my breaker panel.

I've got about 40 feet of the 8 guage in place feeding a storage cottage behind my house but I plan to do my sawing about 20 feet away from that. So, I'll most likely install a 240 outlet at the cottage and then make a 6 guage extension cord to power the motor. I personally single handedly built what was supposed to be my shed but my spouse found it looking pretty cute so she claimed it as her "Cottage". Oh well!!


The saw blade weighs 25 lbs. + a 1" x 48" steel shaft at 10 lbs. plus two sheaves at maybe 5 lbs.(to bump the 1750 rpm up to something less than my blades max. 2850 rpm) and 68" of 5/8" belt maybe 1 lb = around 41 lbs. The shaft will ride smoothly in 4 pillow bearings. Sounds well under your functioning 70lbs so, I'm in good shape.

BTW for starting capacitors I cheated on mine and used a pair of old 450 VDC 2800 uf electrolytics from a old industrial power supply. I have then wired reverse series with ones positive as the input then their negative terminals tied in series with the second capacitors positive as the output. SO far I have never had an issue with them working that way even though they take a 100 or so amp current through them for 3 - 10 seconds while the compressor gets up to speed.
The reverse series connection makes them work as an equivalent to a 1400 uf 300 VAC motor start capacitor. ;)

A neat idea! I've not seen that done before. I'll probably follow your lead.

For your 15 HP motor I would start out with around 150 uf for each of the phase balancing capacitors and at least 1000 uf for the starting capacitor. The size of the starting capacitor determines the starting torque and thus starting speed up time and starting amp load.
WONDERFUL!!
I expect to find what I need on e-bay,

Thanks again.
Ed aka machapungo
 

Thread Starter

machapungo

Joined Jan 17, 2014
20
Good to know and if you need help on the setup when you get your parts together let us know. :)[/QUOTE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
OKAY! Thanks!! Not sure how long it will take to set up a test bench for this rig. my spouse is planning a big bathroom renovation that will, at least, delay the final implementation and maybe the test bench a bit.

I have motor and all the mechanical parts and have ordered the electrical stuff.
I think I'm doing pretty good on the electrical parts via e-bay.

Two [SIZE=+1]new 3300uf, 20%[/SIZE], 450v electrolytic caps. $11.99 each.
Two new non-polar film caps. 150 uf , 450v $12.55 ea

Two unused 200amp, 220volt vintage contactors @ $40.00 each. I will use one to apply 220v input power via a on/off switch and safety via a red emergency off button.
The other will be used with the start-up capacitors in series with a start up switch..
I have decided to, at least initially, not use that fancy automated start switch. Instead, I will us a manually operated spring loaded button to activate the contactor. I plan to train my finger to operate it properly.

Four AC 300V 50A Digital Voltmeter Ammeter LED Amp Volt Meter ... $10.59 each.These have current pick up coils. I plan to monitor all 3 motor legs and source V & I.
This is probably "overkill" but I thought it would be a nice & easy way to see what's happening. I plan to place one on the input line and one on each 120 degree leg. Hopefully informative.

One on / off switch. One emergency off red button. One stainless spring loaded start button. All at reasonable prices and no shipping charges for any of the above. I bought the motor from a local friend who buys and sells package deals on used stuff for $80.
Even so, the costs are adding up, as usual!!!


 

tcmtech

Joined Nov 4, 2013
2,867
And yet when you are done you will have less into it than what your wife will spend just on towels for the new bathroom. :rolleyes:

Where did you find 150 uf 450 volt non polar capacitor at for $12.55 each?

I spend about $15 each on 100 uf 370 VAC power factor correction (motor run) capacitors. :(
 
Top