Discussion in 'Physics' started by amilton542, May 6, 2011.
If a magnet was left in space till the end of time would it still be as strong as it originally was?
The end of time is a long way off.
If it was at absolute zero, it might just.
Then there must be a demagnetizing force acting on the magnet
Well, there will be varying magnetic fields out there, regardless of how tiny, and in the real universe there will be some temperature. Given forever, they are likely to get the job done.
BTW, I meant if it were at absolute zero, temperature wise, the magnetic field might just last forever.
Cosmic radiation would probably have an effect.
Being the end of time - who (or whom) will be around to check one way or the other? If so will they really be all that interested. If they were still around (and interested) they probably already knew the outcome in advance.
It's an interesting philosophical question.
If a man does something and no woman is around to see it, did he still do it wrong?
I just asked my wife and she verified.
Always nice to have expert advice handy.
If the magnet was in a sterile vacuum that is absent from the dangers of space there must always be something that will demagnetize the magnet because nothing lasts forever.
I think any civilization at that time scraping an existence around a red dwarf would have more important things to worry about, o well
If it were possible to isolate the magnet from all external influences then there would be nothing to demagnetize it.
If nothing lasts forever does the magnet itself physically vanish before it demagnetizes?
I didn't think about that one. YES the magnet would vanish before it demagnetizes
Yet if it vanishes energy must be created, so the vacuum is no longer perfect and sterile.
wouldn't that depend on ones definition of 'vanished'?
Then there's always the First Law of Thermodynamics to contend with.
or another issue regarding observers ...
"If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?"
I think the magnets own magnetism is a demagnetising force.
There are two forces that demagnetizes a magnet, heat and mechanical shock. If it were cold and static I think it would last quite a while. Probably longer than humans.
Have I missed something?
No, the universe is still here - I think....???
Perhaps we have wandered into metaphysics.