Error in : The transistor as a switch

Thread Starter

Unregistered

Joined Dec 31, 1969
0
The figures on the page:

http://www.allaboutcircuits.com/vol_3/chpt_4/2.html

illustrating use of a transistor as a switch are labeled incorrectly. The labels are:

(a) mechanical switch, (b) PNP transistor switch, (c) NPN transistor switch.

They Should be

(a) mechanical switch, (b) NPN transistor switch , (c) PNP transistor switch

Also, the battery should be reversed in case of the PNP transistor switch illustration, to maintain correct perception of comparison.
 

Wendy

Joined Mar 24, 2008
23,429
If you are talking about this drawing...



(a) mechanical switch, (b) PNP transistor switch, (c) NPN transistor switch.

I have to agree entirely.

For figure C I would switch battery polarity, and match it to (b)
 

Dcrunkilton

Joined Jul 31, 2004
422

(a) mechanical switch, (b) NPN transistor switch, (c) PNP transistor switch.

I swapped NPN and PNP at (b) and (c) above as suggested. Since the PNP at (c) is drawn upside down the battery polarity is correct as is; the collector is (-) battery.

copy at ibiblio is updated.
 
Last edited:
Top