Do heating elements have high or low resistances?

Thread Starter

mahela007

Joined Jul 25, 2008
45
Does the heating element in something like an electric hot water heater have high resistance or low resistance? I can't seem to find the answer the to that question. If it has low resistance , then why does the filament of a incandescent light bulb have high resistance?
 

scubasteve_911

Joined Dec 27, 2007
1,203
Heaters and lightbulbs have low resistance.

For example , a 100W bulb. P = V^2/R

R = V^2/P
= 144 Ohms

1000W heater
R = 120^2/1000
= 14.4 Ohms

Keep in mind that this resistance is 'dynamic'. During startup, there is a much lower resistance seen. This is because as the filament heats, it's resistance increases. Therefore, the current goes down.

Steve
 

scubasteve_911

Joined Dec 27, 2007
1,203
I thought about that a bit more, and the answer is relative. Yes, the lightbulb's filament is high resistance in comparison to the wire used to connect it to the AC supply. But, it's certainly not high in comparison to a typical resistor used in an opamp circuit.

Steve
 

DickCappels

Joined Aug 21, 2008
10,175
"Does the heating element in something like an electric hot water heater have high resistance or low resistance?"

Yes! Next question, please...

More seriously:
Hi or low compared to what?

It will have the resistance required to dissipate the required power. It will be higher than the resistance of a penny but lower than the resistance of a 100 watt light bulb.
 
Top