Which forum should circuit simulation discussions go in?

Discussion in 'Feedback and Suggestions' started by Alec_t, Sep 24, 2016.

  1. Alec_t

    Thread Starter AAC Fanatic!

    Sep 17, 2013
    5,766
    1,101
    Circuit simulation and PCB layout design of a general nature does not fit happily in any of the existing fora. Suggestions?
     
    absf and #12 like this.
  2. jpanhalt

    AAC Fanatic!

    Jan 18, 2008
    5,671
    899
    What about General Electronics Chat?

    John
     
  3. crutschow

    Expert

    Mar 14, 2008
    12,976
    3,220
    Should the moderators consider adding a forum for PCB Design and Circuit simulation?
     
  4. jpanhalt

    AAC Fanatic!

    Jan 18, 2008
    5,671
    899
    I think those are two very different subjects. Design will have a lot to do with the mechanics (e.g., trace widths) or the software used. Simulation deals with how it works irrespective of the design.

    I don't have a problem with having new sub-forums, but I do think they should not be an electronic stew. That is what chat is for.

    John
     
    Aleph(0) and #12 like this.
  5. crutschow

    Expert

    Mar 14, 2008
    12,976
    3,220
    Some PCB layout programs also do circuit simulation and vice versa so there is some connection between the two.
    And layout is often about more than just the mechanics of the layout. Trace lengths and parasitic capacitances and inductances can affect the operation of many circuits, which in turn, can affect the simulation parameters.

    I don't understand what you mean by "Simulation deals with how it works irrespective of the design." :confused:
    What design?
     
  6. #12

    Expert

    Nov 30, 2010
    16,248
    6,744
    The design of the physical layout?

    Personally, I like the idea of a Simulation forum. I meet a lot of Chat Threads that look like design problems and they are really simulation problems.
    "Help. My simulation shows something is wrong with the circuit."
    No, it shows something is wrong with the simulation.
    I can figure out a schematic. I don't know squat about simulating one with a computer.
     
  7. crutschow

    Expert

    Mar 14, 2008
    12,976
    3,220
    Do the Moderators want to weigh in on this?
     
    absf and #12 like this.
  8. OBW0549

    Well-Known Member

    Mar 2, 2015
    1,300
    879
    I can see the value in having a forum dedicated to discussing PCB layout, a place for threads about PCB CAD software, sources, and usage and about board layout practices. Board layout is an activity that is usually (but not always, see #5 above) distinct from circuit design and has its own set of issues. Giving it its own forum might not be a bad idea.

    If we create a forum for circuit simulation it would be best to restrict it to general discussion of simulation software and its usage, but NOT as a mandatory repository for all threads in which someone posts an LTSpice (for example) circuit diagram and plot to illustrate some question (or solution) he has regarding a circuit he is working on. The latter posts, in my opinion, still belong in whichever of the existing forums they would normally go in absent any reference to simulation.
     
    JohnInTX and #12 like this.
  9. JohnInTX

    Moderator

    Jun 26, 2012
    2,339
    1,020
    (Emphasis added) OBW's comment fixes one of my concerns - that any given thread can include topics on several of the current forum topics. That said, I think a separate category would be helpful to address general how-to questions of simulation, emulation etc. as well as specific information pertaining to learning LT-Spice, TINA, Proteus et. al. It could become a valuable resource.

    Makes sense to me.
     
  10. MrChips

    Moderator

    Oct 2, 2009
    12,414
    3,353
    I vote for two separate forums
    • PCB Layout
    • Circuit Simulation
     
    absf, JohnInTX and #12 like this.
  11. crutschow

    Expert

    Mar 14, 2008
    12,976
    3,220
    I second MrChips' motion.
     
  12. tindel

    Active Member

    Sep 16, 2012
    567
    193
    I'm no Mod - but - At first I appreciated the additional forums but I think it's getting a little carried away... There are currently 22(!!!) forums... and I'm starting to get lost in how many clicks I need to perform to read what interests me. It's getting hard to get where I want to go and make sure I see all of the new posts without seeing 1M posts about people's homework (which I don't care for). I rarely get beyond checking 3 forums before I get bored clicking back and fourth. For instance I like seeing other people's projects, but I have a hard time remembering that there is another forum for projects. Right now I click Analog, Power, and General and rarely get further than that.

    Simple is always better in my mind. I'd arrange them something like this:
    Analog
    Automotive
    Digital & Embedded
    Power
    RF
    Other Electronics - Basically for anything that does pertain to electronics but not to the above forums.
    Projects
    Completed Projects
    Homework & Education
    Off-Topic & Forum Suggestions


    I'd personally say that PCB Layout and Simulation should go in the section that the circuit is simulating (i.e. rf, analog, digital, etc) rather than adding another two forums.

    I'd also get more vigalent about moving topics that obviously don't go in certain forums. Right now there is a senior design project in general that should be moved to homework (or possibly projects).
     
    Last edited: Oct 22, 2016
  13. tindel

    Active Member

    Sep 16, 2012
    567
    193
    I just realized i cam essentially ignore forums by 'watching' forums i am interested in. I'll probably miss some topics I'm interested in but will probably hit 80% or so.

    My suggestions still stand because new people coming in will probably still be overwhelmed by the number of choices
     
  14. OBW0549

    Well-Known Member

    Mar 2, 2015
    1,300
    879
    It seems like most requests for assistance with schoolwork are being posted anywhere BUT the "Homework Help" forum these days. Some eventually get moved to that forum by the moderators, but not all. I'm not interested in giving homework help, so the presence of these posts in other forums is more than a bit annoying. To me, anyway...
     
    Aleph(0) and Hypatia's Protege like this.
  15. #12

    Expert

    Nov 30, 2010
    16,248
    6,744
    That's what the, "Report" button is for.
     
  16. OBW0549

    Well-Known Member

    Mar 2, 2015
    1,300
    879
    Yes, I'm well aware of that, thank you. I use it frequently.
     
  17. Hypatia's Protege

    Distinguished Member

    Mar 1, 2015
    2,778
    1,211
    Agreed! -- Unfortunately it has been my observation (well... suspicion) that many said 'misplacements' are little more than machinations of members with the aim of 'outsourcing' their assignments - sans the least interest in study or comprehension:rolleyes:

    Best regards
    HP
     
  18. #12

    Expert

    Nov 30, 2010
    16,248
    6,744
    It works for me, consistently. I think I've made about 2 calls to move a Thread in all my time here that didn't go as I expected.
    With a process in place that seems to work almost all the time, I can't find room to complain.
     
  19. Alec_t

    Thread Starter AAC Fanatic!

    Sep 17, 2013
    5,766
    1,101
    Like HP, I suspect that some homework questions are deliberately posted in other forums to avoid the 'we don't do your homework for you' response.
     
    Hypatia's Protege likes this.
  20. GopherT

    AAC Fanatic!

    Nov 23, 2012
    5,980
    3,706
    I don't think it matters a bit anymore which sub-forum is used for any topic. Right now, the first thread in each of the first three subforums is about Pwm power supplies.
     
    atferrari and djsfantasi like this.
Loading...