Calling on the kindness of transistor experts, as this one has me stumped. Ive got a transistor output power amp with an op-amp for the error amplifier, in a circuit remarkably similar to the one on pages 6 and 7 of LT App Note AN18 (5.6 MB).
My problem is that with the HT supply rails at ±50 V, the output transistors keep frying themselves due to thermal runaway. Its much more behaved at ±45 V, and occasionally a pair of transistors will survive at ±50 V, so it looks like its marginal. The transistors are little SOT-23 devices ( FMMT458 (130 KB) and FMMT558 (121 KB)) and the bias circuit diodes are 1N4148WT (131 KB). These diodes are so tiny its possible to put three of the things side by side on top of a SOT-23 package. On the prototype, each diode is soldered directly to the leg of the relevant transistor, so the thermal coupling is about as good as it gets.
The emitter resistors are 10 Ω, the circuit has been blowing up with an open-circuit load, and there are no traces of instability. Normally the circuit drives a 6 H inductive load via a 100 Ω series resistor, and it will quite happily do this all day with slightly lower HT rails. The no-signal no-load quiescent currents through the output transistors are (initially) tiny, measured at about 4 μA.
I can make the problem go away (higher ambient temperature tests pending) by only using one bias diode, but with larger sized output transistors a two-diode bias should be erring on the side of caution. Is there something subtle going on because of the small sized (and hence quick-to-warm-up) transistors, where I may have reached a limit on the bias levels? I know some small modern MOSFETs can have a critical current density threshold where they are prone to thermal runaway and secondary breakdown if they are operated below this threshold (the current density tempco flips at this crucial point), but Ive never heard the like with bipolar devices.
So does anyone know whats going on here? Any ideas on the subject will be much appreciated. Im not looking for a fix (its easily fettled), just an understanding.
My problem is that with the HT supply rails at ±50 V, the output transistors keep frying themselves due to thermal runaway. Its much more behaved at ±45 V, and occasionally a pair of transistors will survive at ±50 V, so it looks like its marginal. The transistors are little SOT-23 devices ( FMMT458 (130 KB) and FMMT558 (121 KB)) and the bias circuit diodes are 1N4148WT (131 KB). These diodes are so tiny its possible to put three of the things side by side on top of a SOT-23 package. On the prototype, each diode is soldered directly to the leg of the relevant transistor, so the thermal coupling is about as good as it gets.
The emitter resistors are 10 Ω, the circuit has been blowing up with an open-circuit load, and there are no traces of instability. Normally the circuit drives a 6 H inductive load via a 100 Ω series resistor, and it will quite happily do this all day with slightly lower HT rails. The no-signal no-load quiescent currents through the output transistors are (initially) tiny, measured at about 4 μA.
I can make the problem go away (higher ambient temperature tests pending) by only using one bias diode, but with larger sized output transistors a two-diode bias should be erring on the side of caution. Is there something subtle going on because of the small sized (and hence quick-to-warm-up) transistors, where I may have reached a limit on the bias levels? I know some small modern MOSFETs can have a critical current density threshold where they are prone to thermal runaway and secondary breakdown if they are operated below this threshold (the current density tempco flips at this crucial point), but Ive never heard the like with bipolar devices.
So does anyone know whats going on here? Any ideas on the subject will be much appreciated. Im not looking for a fix (its easily fettled), just an understanding.