I got some good help from you guys in this thread, and I'm hoping you can help out again.
This is for the same project: an LED-based torchiere lamp. Cooling for the LED's is to be supplied by an 80mm-square fan, 1" tall. My power supply (discussed at the above link) allows for an adjustable DC supply voltage to the fan, so I can dial the fan RPM down to the lowest (quietest) speed that provides adequate cooling.
Well, I picked this Sunon fan. They brag about their unique bearings and how quiet their fans are, so I decided to try one out. I suppose the bearing itself is quiet, and there's not much wind noise when I slow it down, but the big problem seems to be mechanical vibrations due to the torque pulses caused by the fan's internal ESC switching the current on/off to the motor's poles. Those torque pulses get transmitted to a sheet-metal ductwork assembly that I've built for directing the airflow to the heat sinks, and of course that sheet metal vibrates accordingly. It's unacceptably noisy.
I haven't tried soft-mounting the fan yet; that's something to do this weekend, and will involve securing the fan with soft foam cushions instead of screws. But...if that doesn't work, can anyone recommend an 80mm square fan that really does run quiet? Not just wind noise or bearing noise, but something that mitigates those torque pulses?
This is for the same project: an LED-based torchiere lamp. Cooling for the LED's is to be supplied by an 80mm-square fan, 1" tall. My power supply (discussed at the above link) allows for an adjustable DC supply voltage to the fan, so I can dial the fan RPM down to the lowest (quietest) speed that provides adequate cooling.
Well, I picked this Sunon fan. They brag about their unique bearings and how quiet their fans are, so I decided to try one out. I suppose the bearing itself is quiet, and there's not much wind noise when I slow it down, but the big problem seems to be mechanical vibrations due to the torque pulses caused by the fan's internal ESC switching the current on/off to the motor's poles. Those torque pulses get transmitted to a sheet-metal ductwork assembly that I've built for directing the airflow to the heat sinks, and of course that sheet metal vibrates accordingly. It's unacceptably noisy.
I haven't tried soft-mounting the fan yet; that's something to do this weekend, and will involve securing the fan with soft foam cushions instead of screws. But...if that doesn't work, can anyone recommend an 80mm square fan that really does run quiet? Not just wind noise or bearing noise, but something that mitigates those torque pulses?