mesh analysis prblm

Thread Starter

goldfinger

Joined Jun 26, 2010
3
Hi!!
In the prblm below we've to find power dissipated in 2Ω resistor.



If I apply KVL to the outermost loop i'll get : 5 ia= 30
so, ia = 6A, which is wrong soln.(Why :confused:)

Similarly,if I apply KVL as below:
30-5 ia -3( ia -2.5)-6 ia = 0, i'll get: ia = 2.67A, which is again wrong(Why:confused:)
But, if I apply KVL as below:
30-5 ia -3( ia -2.5)-4(ia -2.5+2)=0, i'll get : ia =3.29A,which is correct.
Once ia is known then voltage acrss 2Ω= 30-6 ia = 10.25 V
Hence, P=(10.25*10.25)/2 = 52.53W Ans.
 

Georacer

Joined Nov 25, 2009
5,182
If I apply KVL to the outermost loop i'll get : 5 ia= 30
so, ia = 6A, which is wrong soln.(Why :confused:)
Similarly,if I apply KVL as below:
30-5 ia -3( ia -2.5)-6 ia = 0, i'll get: ia = 2.67A, which is again wrong(Why:confused:)
This is not quite correct. A current source doesn't produce zero voltage on its edges. It produces as much voltage as it needs to let a current equal to its specified value run through it, and generally this voltage is unknown. This is the reason KVL doesn't yield the correct result. In your third mesh, where you didn't incude a current source, you didn't do that mistake and got the correct answer.
 
Top