
Homework Help Stuck on a textbook question or coursework? Cramming for a test and need help understanding something? Post your questions and attempts here and let others help. 

Thread Tools  Display Modes 
#1




Help me calculate the power developed by this simple circuit.
Homework question: Find the total energy developed in the circuit.
The first thing I need help understanding is: is this question supposed to be asking for power instead of "energy." How can you calculate the energy developed without some type of time constraint? Ok, so assuming we are talking about power developed, here is what I know: First, I know that i = 8 A so the dependent current source is always equal to 24 A. Second, I must calculate the power absorbed by each element by using the formula I*V. (Of course we will use the formula I*V if the current is moving in the direction of the voltage rise). So the power absorbed by the 20V voltage source and the 100V voltage source is 160 Watts and 1600 Watts. And since these numbers are negative that tells us that power is being delivered. So I figured out that these two elements are developing 1760 W of power, but I can't find the power created or absorbed by the current sources because I can't create 3 independent equations to find the three remaining voltages across the terminals of the current sources. (KVL only yield two such equations) How do I find the power absorbed or delivered by these 3 remaining circuit elements? P.S. the answer key says the answer is 220 W so I know my answer of 1760 W is already way off! 
#2




One thing you can say with certainty is that with the answer key stating the answer in terms of Watts then your initial question is answered outright.
hgmjr Last edited by hgmjr; 06102007 at 02:33 PM. 
#3




haha... good point.

#4




Since power is additive and always a positive quantity, then I am at a loss as to how the answer can be 220 Watts since you already have 1760 Watts. This is well in excess of the value given in the answer key.
Either I have overlooked something or the answer in the answer key is for a different problem or the circuit as drawn has an error. hgmjr 
#5




NichA,
I would say that no power is dissapated in the circuit because no resistance exists. Please post the solution when you receive it. Ratch 
#6




I don't suppose the thing that says 3i is in fact a 660V source?
Try that. 
#7




I would assume there are an infinite range of possible circuit conditions but the nett energy loss is always zero.
Assume any voltage from +∞ to ∞ across the 3i controlled source and you have always have power balance as the voltage magnitude increases with either polarity. Take the case of +20 volts across the controlled source. The 8A source would have zero voltage drop and the 16A source would have 80V drop. Source Powers in that case 20V source = +160W [supplying power] 100V source = +1600W [supplying power] 8A source = 0 W 16A source = 1280W [absorbing power] Controlled source = 480W [absorbing power] So the total power input balances the total absorbed power. Take the case of 50V across the controlled source. The 8A source would have 70V drop The 16A source would have 150V drop Source powers in that case 20V source = +160W as always 100V source = +1600W as always 8A source = 560W 16A source = 2400W controlled source = +1200W Once again the supplied & absorbed powers balance. Seems a rather pointless question. 
#8




Perhaps a final comment ....
Imagine a very high resistance value shunting the controlled source. Let's say it's 100MΩ. No current would flow in this resistor since the controlled source just balances the total independent current source output. By the same reasoning the shunting resistor would add no power loss to the system. Given there is no current then there would be zero voltage drop across the resistor. So the controlled source potential difference would be zero. The controlled source would neither absorb or generate any power. In that case the two independent current sources would absorb the 1760W derived from the two independent voltage sources. No other losses would need explanation since none would exist. One can probably equally well reason that the shunting resistor could be any value (including 0Ω ...?) and there would be no power loss due to the presence of the resistor, irrespective of its ohmic value. The proposed answer alluding to the mysterious & unaccounted loss of 220W continues to puzzle me. One could, for instance, place a resistance of 0.382 ohms in series with the controlled source and thereby produce the required 220W. I wonder if the OP has inadvertently omitted any circuit elements in transcribing the schematic...? Last edited by t_n_k; 08032011 at 11:44 AM. 
#9




AFAIK an ideal current source has zero volts across it. Thus the left leg has 20V across it, and the middle leg has 100V across it.
But as these two legs are in parallel, there cannot be two different voltages. Thus the question is in error in at least 2 places. Addendum: Power in watts is equivalent to joules per second. Joules is energy. One *could* ask how much energy does it consume/emit in some given time. But without specifying how much time then the energy is indeterminate.
__________________
“Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same, or one day we will spend our sunset years telling our children and our children’s children what it was once like in the United States where men were free.” 
#10




That's incorrect.
Imagine an ideal current source of 1A driving a 1Ω load. The source has 1V across it. An ideal current source adjusts its terminal voltage to keep the current in the load constant. Last edited by t_n_k; 08042011 at 04:56 AM. 
Tags 
calculate, circuit, developed, power, simple 
Related Site Pages  
Section  Title  
Worksheet  AC power  
Textbook  AC bridge circuits : Ac Metering Circuits  
Textbook  Mutual inductance and basic operation : Transformers  
Worksheet  Energy, Work, and Power  
Textbook  An electric pendulum : Resonance 
Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
need help with remote access power (off/on) circuit  earlt  The Projects Forum  7  11052009 02:19 AM 
Math Help with a Simple LED circuit  fish4fun  The Projects Forum  3  03032009 04:04 AM 
Simple 12V "UPS" Circuit  danf100  The Projects Forum  8  01122009 08:46 PM 
Simple Capacitor and Resistor Circuit  exidez  Homework Help  5  09162008 02:20 AM 
Power Calculations in an Unbalanced 3 Phase Circuit  Houdini  General Electronics Chat  1  12132007 01:23 PM 
Thread Tools  
Display Modes  

