All About Circuits Forum  

Go Back   All About Circuits Forum > Abstract Forums > Physics

Notices

Physics Discussion forum for anything physics related.

Closed Thread   Post New Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 05-16-2008, 07:18 AM
Ratch Ratch is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 1,068
Default Ohm's law is not V=IR

As promised, I would like to call your attention to a misnomer in electrical science of the formula V = I*R, which is wrongly called Ohm's law.

First I will show a couple of links.

http://maxwell.byu.edu/~spencerr/web...00000000000000

http://www.launc.tased.edu.au/online...Resistance.htm

Still not convinced? Don't blame you. One can publish anything the WWW.

OK, let's look next at a couple of good physics texts.

I will first quote from a college textbook called Physics, by Halliday & Resnick, 1967, page 780. It was written by David Halliday, Professor of Physics, University of Pittsburgh and Robert Resnick, Professor of Physics, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"We stress the relationship V=I*R is NOT a statement of Ohm's law. A
conductor obeys Ohm's law only if its V vs. I curve is linear, that is, if R
is independent of V and I. The relationship R=V/I remains as the general
definition of the resistance of a conductor whether or not the conductor
obeys Ohm's law. . . . . . . . . Ohm's law is a specific property of
certain materials and is NOT a general law of electromagnetism, for example,
like Gauss's law."
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Next a quote from another college textbook called Physics for Scientists & Engineers, by
Raymond Serway, Third Edition, 1990, page 745. It was written by Raymond A. Serway of James Madison University

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"A current density J and an electric field E are established in a
conductor when a potential difference is maintained across the conductor.
If the potential difference is constant, the current will also be constant.
Very often, the current density in a conductor is proportional to the
electric field in the conductor. that is J=sigma*E where sigma is called the
conductivity of the conductor. Materials that obey the above equation are
said to follow Ohm's law, named after Georg Simon Ohm (1787-1854). More
specifically,

Ohm's law states that for many materials (including most metals) the
ratio of the current density and electric field is a constant, sigma, which is
independent of the electric field producing the current.

Materials that obey Ohm's law, and hence demonstrate this linear
behavior between E and J, are said to be ohmic. The electrical behavior of
most materials is quite linear for very small changes in the current.
Experimentally, one finds that not all materials have this property.
Materials that do not obey Ohm's law are said to be nonohmic. Ohm's law is
not a fundamental law of nature, but an empirical relationship valid only
for certain materials."
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

OK, what could be clearer? Ohm's law refers to the linearity between voltage and current, not relationship between voltage, current, and resistance. Yet the formula, V = I*R has been misnamed across countless classrooms, books and discussions. What does your textbook or school teach?

To summarize, certain materials like conductive metals follow Ohm's law, in that their V vs.I curve is linear. Ohm's law is a property of a material, not a general law of nature. Other conductive entities like diode junctions or gas discharge bulbs do not have the Ohm's law property, because their conductivity changes depending on what voltage or current is applied, causing their V vs. I curve to be nonlinear. In all cases, V = I*R is always correct, but it should not be called Ohm's law. It should be called the resistance or impedance formula.

No matter what you call V = I*R, circuits will still get designed and analyzed, and science will still progress.

Ratch
  #2  
Old 05-17-2008, 01:31 AM
triggernum5 triggernum5 is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 216
Default

Yet in any specific test conditions, Ohm's law must hold for conservational purposes.. ie. a material with a varying resistance, will have a certain resistance under the current conditions..
Analogous to a thermistor in a circuit, except its resistance varies due to temperature, rather than potential..
Ohm's law does hold for non-ohmic materials, but R is a function, not a constant..
  #3  
Old 05-17-2008, 01:44 AM
Ratch Ratch is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 1,068
Default

triggernum5,

Quote:
Yet in any specific test conditions, Ohm's law must hold for conservational purposes.. ie. a material with a varying resistance, will have a certain resistance under the current conditions..
The resistance/impedance formula will hold under any voltage and current condition. That formula is not Ohm's law.

Quote:
Ohm's law does hold for non-ohmic materials, but R is a function, not a constant..
Contradictory statement. If a material is non-ohmic, then it does not follow Ohm's law. Ohm's law is a property of a material, not a method of determining resistance from the voltage and current. Ratch
  #4  
Old 05-17-2008, 03:41 AM
triggernum5 triggernum5 is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 216
Default

Well thats a debate over language and semantics.. Those tend to kill quality technical discussion, but I won't disagree with that..
Closed Thread   Post New Thread

Tags
, ,


Related Site Pages
Section Title
Worksheet Calculus for electric circuits
Worksheet Summer and subtractor opamp circuits
Worksheet Class A BJT amplifiers
Worksheet Capacitance
Worksheet Inductance
Worksheet Magnetic units of measurement
Video Lecture Electrical Quantities B - Basic Electronics and Units of Measure
Textbook Specific resistance : Physics Of Conductors And Insulators
Textbook Nonlinear conduction : Ohm's Law
Textbook How voltage, current, and resistance relate : Ohm's Law


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Ohm's Law for Noobies...or The Amp Hour Fallacy #12 General Electronics Chat 1 05-07-2012 04:40 AM
Small Signal BJT Amplifier kaname08 The Projects Forum 27 03-09-2012 03:35 PM
n00b needs some help with Ohms law @work stormBytes General Electronics Chat 27 09-05-2010 01:45 AM
Rambling on--A continuation of "What is Ohm's Law?" Ratch Off-Topic 1 12-30-2008 04:43 PM

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:31 PM.


User-posted content, unless source quoted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Public Domain License.
Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.